The Thrustmaster Hotas works very well. Got one myself a couple of weeks ago and used it with this simulator to practice for the ASTB. Before I found this simulator, I took the ASTB in March 2025 and got a 50 5/7/6. Just retook the test today and got a 58 8/9/9. This simulator was perfect. For reference, if you can get consistent 100-120 for scores on the hardest difficulty on the sim, you will pass easily on the test. For the other parts of the test, I used two ASTB apps on iPhone (one costs about $40 but really helps with the OAR, ANIT, and the performance tests).