So, hypothetically speaking, what sort of beer do you imagine that this so-called "class advisor" would like? Or might this mythical person prefer some Pappy?
Hypothetically of course.
Eh, whatever beer fine payments are available in the fridge. My fav beer is "Free", my second favorite is "Free Light". And who doesn't love Pappy?
As to @Treetop Flyer 's comments, that sucks and I remember similar types of folks from my SNA time. I think every squadron is a bit different and the quality/variation of instruction background is pretty good these days. We had/have tacair types from Blue and Green, AD and Reserves. I actively encourage my students to put in for Tailhook if it's their desire and they have the grades, and I do the best I can to relate Carrier Air Wing fleet life to them from my 150' perspective. If anything, I make fun of the VP dudes.

Realistically, we've been told, most VFA/VAQ types won't get a VT(P) slot due to the demand elsewhere for their skill sets in shore tours. It is what it is.