I just don't get this. So he DQ'ed at the boat after winging, but he still made it through the syllabus, which is essentially a PQS to earn wings (I'm oversimplifying, I know, but you get my point). Not everyone can be a tailhooker, get over it. I understand losing the wings if it's a safety issue, but if the FENAB said he can keep the wings, then so be it.
It seems to me (and I know it's only my perception) that these are the same guys that tend to give jet guys bad names. Not directed at you, Flash, as I understand you're stating the facts of the situation.