Physical fitness vs. intelligence
jung said "So is it fair to say that the Marines emphasize physical fitness over intelligence? I don't mean to offend anyone here."
stevew said "I think intelligent Marine is oximoronic, j/k To make it as a marine you must be very physically fit. There are academic standards a marine must meet but it is by no means nuclear physics."
I'm not sure I understand the "spirit" of these two comments as they relate to the posted topic. If I understand this correctly, this is a thread concerning Marine Corps OCS and the original post concerned comments given by a particular OSO to a prospective candidate about meeting certain physical fitness "standards". It is certainly debatable whether or not the OSO comments were correct. However, references to GPA/academic standards/intelligence were not mentioned in jung's original question. Academic guidelines can be found in other threads. I suppose jung must have made a "leap in logic" after seeing the other posts on physical guidelines required for acceptance into OCS to assume those who "exercise their muscles" haven't also "excercised their brains". However, it is not fair to say that the Marine Corps OCS emphasizes "brawn over brain". By the way, jung, no offense was taken. I realize you are just asking a question. With all other things being equal (letters of reference, candidate character, needs of the Marine Corps, etc.), I suspect the Marine Corps might prefer a candidate with a 300 PFT and a 4.0 GPA over a candidate with a 250 PFT and a 4.0 GPA, if they had to choose between these two. However, I'm not so sure they would choose a candidate with a 300 PFT and a 2.0 GPA over one with a 250 PFT and a 4.0 GPA. Selection is not based on one factor alone. It is about balance....although only the Selection Board knows what that balance is.
The Marine Corps places the greatest emphasis on leadership abilities demonstrated at OCS. Certainly physical fitness is very important, as it is necessary to handle the physical rigors while at OCS. That is why there are some minimum guidelines which must be met prior to an OSO sending off a package. Intelligence is also necessary to handle the academic training one receives while at Quantico. That is why all candidates commissioned at OCS must have a college degree.
I hope stevew, the moderator of this particular thread, was speaking in jest when he said "I think intelligent Marine is oximoronic". That was real clever, stevew, but not really appropriate. I'm sure the 165 candidates who received their commission at OCS 184 on December 12, 2003 would be willing to "debate" that comment with you if given the chance. Yes, a Marine Officer is physically fit, although they don't all have a 300 PFT. Yes, an OCS candidate must meet "academic standards". No, it's not nuclear physics, nor do those with less than a college degree become Officers of Marines. Some even majored in physics!