I'm in the "readily available, but never wear them" crowd
(I can hear the "SAFETY VIOLATOR!!!" yelling from here)
There was another pilot who demanded I fly with gloves. I was wearing them when we had to shut down an engine at 1200 feet, at night behind the carrier on an 0% illum night. I had them on, and could not flip PCL checklist pages with them on.
Call me fatalistic, but if there is such a bad fire in the E-2 that I don't have 3 seconds to put my gloves on while dealing with it (I do keep them right in the corner of the glareshield) all the NOMEX in the world is not going to help me as I attempt to unstrap and weasel my way either through a ditching hatch, or through the FEC (which is historically the place that likes to catch on fire)
Not to mention that a bad fire, would also cook my chute as I ran through there.
I didn't wear them flying 60Bs either. I did wear them in the 45 due to the rocket motor strapped to my ass and the MDC on the canopy.