Yeah, ask an Army Aviation Officer what he really thinks about the decision-making skills of his Warrants and you may be surprised. I did that just that a month or so ago with a couple of Apache pilots (Officers, all) who had some pretty negative things to say. Not to mention the fact that they were basically desk-jockeys while the Warrants flew.
/rant
A couple of problems with your assessment.
1) You spoke to an Apache pilot. That should be avoided at all cost at all times, unless you want to hear how great they are. [joke: how can you tell when an Apache pilot is at a party? .......he'll tell you]
2) You spoke with one dude a month ago and took it as fact. Look at some of the knuckleheads you work with (we all have them...or are them...) - how would you like someone to base their assessment of your entire community on one conversation with the office/cockpit idiot?
3) CW3s and especially CW4s rarely make poor decisions. CW2s...yeah, they do...but they are like the LTs of the bunch...still young, inexperienced, and wanting to push the edge. The CW4s that stick around, espcially IP and MTP types, are some of the most sound, prefessional, and competent pilots anywhere. There is no commissioned officer, not one, in the Army that can compete with the experience of a CW4 when it comes to flying. And CW5s? As I said in an earlier thread...people climb mountains to ask them questions.