Marine Reserve officers recieve the same 10 week hell and 6 month Suck as every other officer in the Corps. Does the Navy feel there is some critical differnce in the level of training needed between active and reserve duty. Why does it take 14 weeks to train every other officer but a reservist can do it in 2. Its a joke, seriously. Even if you've gone through the Academy we do the Bulldog program which takes longer then this. Ive been to friggen summer camps that are longer then two weeks. You dont see reserve basic being shortened to 3 full days over the weekend do you. Why would we expect any less from the men leading them.
The Navy does it to suit their needs, simple as that. The DIRCOM program is set up for people like reserve intel types, docs, and other specialists that the Navy needs. If we can get people who have the right skills, like fluency in Arabic or a trauma surgeon, by doing this then I am all for it. Not only that, the people in the DIRCOM program are recruited as staff and restricted line officers, not URL officers that are going to command operational units.
The Marines have the luxury of not needing to staff for these specialties. They are a bare bones force that does not have the support staff or the ancillary duties that the other services have with the exception of JAG's. This includes medical support (Marines use the Navy, obviously), research scientists, specialized logistics and engineering experts. The other services staff places like USAMRIID (United States Army Medical Research Institute of Infectious Diseases), the DOD intelligence services (Marines are few and far between at them), and research/testing facilities like the NRL and U.S. Army Tank Automotive Research, Development and Engineering Center (where do you think they put the M-1 and Hummer through their paces?). Even the large scale logistics that provides the vast majority of the supplies overseas is handled by the USAF, US Army and the Military Sealift Command (you think 60 C-130's provide the USMC in OIF and OEF all of their beans and bullets?). All of the other services have specialized officers and staff for these respective functions (the Army Quartermaster Corps even has officers who specialize in running oil refinery facilities and port facilities, they are sometimes responsible for that stuff in a war zone).
So while the USMC does an admirable job, there are simply functions that the other services perform that require specialists who really don't need to go through OCS/NROTC/Academy and DIRCOM fits the bill. The USMC does not have officers (PhD/MD's) studying the DNA of the latest in bilogical threats, the US Army does. Same thing with the USAF and Navy.
There is a method to the madness, you just have to look at the bigger picture.......