Steve,
You are probably right. My intent was that right now his focus should be on what will get him his commision. I read into his post that it ws volunteer work for the sake of his OCS package in which case a high PFT will be much more valuable. I sometimes bristle at things like comrels during liberty calls, I know it is noble and helping people is good etc but by being out on deployment away from loved ones and very often in harms way I think this does more to support your community than ladling soup out on a couple of weekends.
Point taken though it probably was short sighted.
Gotcha, and to an extent I agree. I think doing volunteer work for the sake of any type of application whether it be for this or even college/grad school/law school is transparent and can easily be identified by the selection board. If, however, there is a long term trend in a person volunteering his/her time, then that says something altogether different. I agree that his time would be better well spent focusing on getting in the highest caliber of shape possible. Certainly, serving in the military is a form of community service.
However, I think most people think that only certain stereotypical volunteer work counts as community service, such as helping out in charities, feeding the hungry on Thanksgiving, etc. These are noble and necessary, but not the only thing people can do to volunteer their time. Coaching Little League (or any other sport for that matter) can be classified as community service. Think of the impact that you can have on young kids. This is but one example, and it's not one of those things you can do when you feel like it. It takes a committment of person's time. To me, community service is just that....service to the community. That should be the first priority. If you can use that as leverage in some application process, then that's just a bonus...but it shouldn't be the goal.