• Please take a moment and update your account profile. If you have an updated account profile with basic information on why you are on Air Warriors it will help other people respond to your posts. How do you update your profile you ask?

    Go here:

    Edit Account Details and Profile

Unusual Vietnam MiG kills

Pags

N/A
pilot
Flash said:
Unfortunately, counting kills back in those days was not a precise science and many kills, both Allied and Axis, have not stood up to historical scrutinity. A well known instance is 'Pappy' Boyngton's score that has been revised downward from 26 or 28 to 22 in many recent history books (but I believe not officially by the USMC) because he was credited with only 2 kills instead of the 6 he claimed in the Flying Tigers.

I've always read that the Luftwaffe had some of the most stringent requirements for kilss. I also read that the USN had some pretty tough requirements, while the 8th AF gave credit for strafing "kills".
 

bunk22

Super *********
pilot
Super Moderator
The Japanese had a very loose standard for kills. It seemed, according to some historians, that if a Japanese pilot fired at a target, it was a kill. Obviously a lot of confusion back in the day with a lot of pilots firing at the same target but not seeing the other pilots firing at the same target. For example, when the Japanese attacked Midway, they shot down 15 aircraft I believe (13 Buffalo's and 2 Wildcats) but claimed 41 kills. In my recollection, only 21 Marine fighters took off to do battle. Standard practice of overclaiming by the Japanese.
 

Flash

SEVAL/ECMO
None
Super Moderator
Contributor
flyingswo said:
One of Chuck Yeager's ME 262 kills was on the ground.

It wasn't credited as an aerial kill. If I remember correctly, the Me-262 that he shot down with while airborne was wheels down and on final approach. This was the preferred method for getting the German jets because they were at their most vunerable.

The criteria to be credited for a kill now is pretty strict. Two guys I knew who worked in the CAOC during OIF described the rules for being credited with a kill as being several pages long, they had a good laugh about it. This was in between all the staff officers talking about what medals they were going to put themselves in for at the end of the war, including Bronze Stars..... :(
 

Flash

SEVAL/ECMO
None
Super Moderator
Contributor
Pags said:
I've always read that the Luftwaffe had some of the most stringent requirements for kilss. I also read that the USN had some pretty tough requirements, while the 8th AF gave credit for strafing "kills".

They are not counted in history books or official kill totals that the USAF keeps for aerial kills. The reasoning behind this was to encourage the fighter pilots to go down low and destroy the Luftwaffe before it coul dget off the ground, a dangerous assignment with a much higher likelyhood getting your a@# shot off.
 

A4sForever

BTDT OLD GUY
pilot
Contributor
bunk22 said:
......Midway.........

MIDWAY then:
Midway3.jpg
Eastern Island in the foreground -- site of the June 1942 airfield. Sand Island is in the background -- site of most other facilities, i.e. Marine ground HQ, Navy Seaplane facility, supply dumps.

MIDWAY now: View from 35,000'. Sand Island is the developed part of the atoll, it has been increased in size with coral dredged from the lagoon. It contains the major jet airfield, seaplane ramps, docks, and all other facilities, buildings, and supply. Eastern Island is basically abandoned and seen peek-a-boo in the first thumbnail.
 

Attachments

  • June 2002 0061.jpg
    June 2002 0061.jpg
    152.7 KB · Views: 51
  • June 2002 0081.jpg
    June 2002 0081.jpg
    126.1 KB · Views: 45
  • June 2002 0091.jpg
    June 2002 0091.jpg
    52.3 KB · Views: 39

A4sForever

BTDT OLD GUY
pilot
Contributor
MIDWAY ISLAND today ...

Of course, the U.S. Navy "owned" Midway before and after June 1942 until about 1996-1997. That was when, by Presidential executive order that the jurisdiction was transferred to Fish & Wildlife (F&W) in the Dept of the Interior. Good deal, you say? Not hardly, as it was then determined that the field could NO LONGER BE USED FOR EMERGENCY BINGOS AS THE "MONEY" TO RUN IT WAS NO LONGER AVAILABLE". This was OUTRAGEOUS !!! :icon_rage

The Dept of Interior has laid many onerous rules & regulations on any visitation to the area (so typical) and you cannot even sail the chain from Honolulu without "special permission" and a transponder on your boat -- to make sure you do not commit the unspeakable "crime" of stopping at any islands on the route. :icon_rage

albatrosseastern.jpg
"GOONEY BIRDS" a.k.a. Laysan albatross
This is the greatest problem with Midway today --- Gooney Birds, and the F&W bureaucrats who believe that the "protection", care and feeding of these Laysan albatross (the PC bureaucrats don't like to call them Gooney Birds -- denigrates 'em) is more important than maintaining an emergency divert field for humans strapped into airplanes. :icon_rage

I was involved in the bureaucratic labyrinth-like process of getting Midway back "on-line" as an emergency divert bingo field. It is still back "on" and "off" and "on" and "off" as the excuse is always given as money. But in reality, (what is that??) it is primarily due to a hard environmental agenda within F&W as well as their bugetary $$$$ and power -- my opinion -- (or is it power and $$$$) -- I can never figure out what the order is .... ?? The two-engine big-birds would have a problem being "legal" without Midway on the trans-Pac routes, so that figured heavily into the mix when the bean-counters became enlightened as to the overwater requirements of aircraft and route certification. Wake is usually too far south of the track system, and as Johnston "glowed" too much in the dark it is now CLOSED. Permanently .... but it was too far south as well. Midway was and is the name of the game.

Arriving.png
CAL 777 in the "HURT LOCKER"
This is a pix of a Continental 777 that landed @ MIDWAY on an emergency divert in early January. HUH?? You mean "it" happens ?? What a suprise, yes ?? :eek:


The current Midway story is interesting and it has since it has nothing to do with "Unusual Vietnam MiG Kills" and I do have a semi-humorous story about Midway and the Navy tower -- perhaps I will transfer "it" over to the 747 thread in COMMERCIAL AVIATION?? Yes?? NO?? MAYBE?? Anyway, more later ....

updatba.gif
ROGER BALL !!
 
Top