I think he got a pass. It was former SH-2F guys who really didn't trust their solution, so they dropped where they thought the target was. Evidently their solution was VERY good, but the launch/impact point was not optimal! Then there was a crew who tried to sink the Thousand Fathoms Club with a double tap to the armament panel. The extorp landed on the island. Not really close to the club, but that was how the story eventually was told. Luckily those incidences occured before I started doing my tours in the block house in Andros.