• Please take a moment and update your account profile. If you have an updated account profile with basic information on why you are on Air Warriors it will help other people respond to your posts. How do you update your profile you ask?

    Go here:

    Edit Account Details and Profile

Russia Tests Nuclear Missile

sevenhelmet

Quaint ideas from yesteryear
pilot
I was a little surprised to see this article this morning- I know we messed around with nuclear missiles in the Cold War era, and they had significant drawbacks- ICBMs won the day. What says the brain trust here- is this posturing, or real threat?

 
Last edited:
I was a little surprised to see this article this morning- I know we messed around with nuclear missiles in the Cold War era, and they had significant drawbacks- ICBMs won the day. What says the brain trust here- is this posturing, or real threat?

Eh. Real-ish.

It’s still a subsonic cruise missile with a nuke warhead, and those are not that hard to kill, though they can be challenging to detect in the sense they have lower launch signature than a ballistic missile, and fly low. Also usually pretty cheap compared to an ICBM to make in swarms - but a nuke powered missile likely is going to increase the cost of building them.

The main benefit over a regular cruise missile is that it can come in from unexpected directions since the massive range means you have the “fuel” to say, submarine launch from the Atlantic, fly over Central America, and go north, instead of just trying to go through our Atlantic coastal defenses. But that basically is only a problem if we don’t have an airborne (or apparently space now) sensor that covers all borders. Pretty much sounds like a snack for a “Golden Dome” network.

Has the feel of yet another Russian “just because we can” science project.
 
I was a little surprised to see this article this morning- I know we messed around with nuclear missiles in the Cold War era, and they had significant drawbacks- ICBMs won the day. What says the brain trust here- is this posturing, or real threat?

I’d go with 60% posturing and 40% real threat. We all know Russia can produce a cruise missile, but an “unlimited range” version is just bombast. Moreover, I think recent ground truth shows us that Putin is all talk and limited capability. For the most part this is more like rattling your butter knife because your saber is dull.
 
Back
Top