It was underpowered ...
Bottom line: a 'tough & fussy' bird down low and in the pattern ...
True dat!! We had a DET from "Heavy Nine", out of Sanford, aboard Sara on my first cruise...was a "nugget" just out of the RAG, early 1960's. As I recall, most of the "Whale" guys did not appreciate the bird...to the point that at least one of their pilots, possibly two, DOR'ed right on the spot after a tough night recovery...also had a Whale parked on the flight deck, forward of the island, for much of the cruise, awaiting off-load (by crane)...a/c had no nose gear, was resting on the forward fuselage...skin all wrinkled up on the star'd side...
On that cruise, during an ORI, I was invited to be an "observer" on an A3 for a "special weapons" delivery...a loft type maneuver, much like what we did with the A1 & A4...but the whale didn't get flat on her back...somewhat like 150*...halfway through, I concluded that I
DID NOT like that event!!
Had a friend (qualified A3 crewman) a few years back...told me this story...he was out on one, (test hop)...they experienced a major engine problem...ordered to bail out...he did, over the LAX area...drifting down in the chute, watched the crew recover power, and fade into the distance. Joe landed in an elderly lady's back yard...made one required call to the local police, then settled back on the gal's patio for hot tea & cookies...when the local po-po arrived, began busting him for the bailout...they thought it was for sport!! The whale landed safely...