• Please take a moment and update your account profile. If you have an updated account profile with basic information on why you are on Air Warriors it will help other people respond to your posts. How do you update your profile you ask?

    Go here:

    Edit Account Details and Profile

Range Report

Bevo16

Registered User
pilot
Last week, I was lucky enough to be a guest at The Mid-South Institute for Self Defense Shooting.

http://www.weaponstraining.com/

For years I had heard stories of this range from a SEAL buddy of mine from college, so actually getting to shoot there was a bit of a dream come true. This place is Disney Land for shooters, and if you wear a SEAL trident, you learned how to shoot at MSI. Any of you can look at the pictures on their web site and see that it is just about 50 acres of ranges, almost all with reactive steel targets. I felt like a kid in a candy store the entire time, but did manage to learn a few things that I would like to share.


Even though I wanted to ride every roller coaster at once, we started off with 9mm on one of the the pistol ranges. First of all, it was a great chance to build confidence. For my first time on a range like that, I handled myself pretty well and all of the work that I had done on my paper range really paid off. I was able to knock down the steel with respectable speed and above average accuracy. Then, the range master shot did some demos...and I was totally humbled. Holy smoke!!! You could drive an aircraft carrier between the difference in my "pretty good" and his "world class". This guy was knocking down the targets with accuracy and keeping no less than 3-4 shell casings in the air at the same time. "Fast" does not begin to describe it. You would think that someone that good would show a tiny bit of ego, but I have never met a more humble and professional instructor. I got some great tips to help with my grip and stance. One of the best things was that he worked with my wife on some of the basics and she really improved quickly.

After spending about an hour and a half on the pistol range, I got to break out the AR and do some longer distance shooting. When I took my rifle out of the bag, it was met with "Oooh, old school. Iron sights only huh?" We had a pretty good optic discussion that I will get into later. The range that I shot my AR on was the long distance one (staying in one place, not a move-n-shoot), with targets of varied sizes out to 150 yards. This range was a real blast, and shooting steel is a lot of fun. I got a real education on 5.56 ballistics, and it is a lot easier to learn in practice than it is reading in a book. It is one thing to read about what the "military zero" means at 100 yards and out, it's another to put in into practice at that range and beyond. I can still see target #7 in my sleep. 3 steel plates about half the size of a sheet of notebook paper at 125 yards...TOUGH. Especially when you are shooting for time. Just for a frame of reference, at that range the target is half the size of your front sight post. Dad always said to set the target right on top of the blade, and Mel Gibson said "aim small, miss small". All good things to remember, along with your 5.56 ballistics. Knowing where your round is on it's flight path is essential to hitting small targets at that distance.

In about 3 hours of shooting, I probably got to use about 10% of the ranges. I can't want to go back and try some of the others.

As far as weapons and ammo go, I was surprised to learn that everyone including one of the nation's top training facilities is having the same trouble getting weapons and ammo that we are. It really is a nation wide issue. I asked if they had a favorite pistol, and they lean towards Sig because that is what the people they train are issued. My M&P didn't get any dirty looks.

As for optics/sights, let me start by explaining why I have stuck with iron sights (for now). First of all, my SEAL Master Chief friend said that he prefers irons over any optic, and he knows better than me. I grew up using iron sights, I am used to them, and have fired thousands of rounds with iron sights. I don't like the idea of becoming over reliant on an electronic gadget or having my life depend on a battery.

At the end of our shooting session, I got to handle the range master's rig and go over why he has it set up the way he does. He had an Aimpoint with 2 MOA dot, irons co-witnessed, a fore grip, and shorter barrel than you can buy off the rack. While I got (mild) compliments for how I handled my irons they made it clear that there was no substitute for the speed of a red dot once you start running and gunning. The fore grip is also really useful for holding the rifle in position while reloading. I had never had one of those before either and had resisted because I had it in my mind that it was more "tacti-cool" than functional. I have probably changed my mind on that.

I will probably make a move on an optic in the next few months, but I am still not sure what I am going to get. Maybe I need to go back and re-read the Aim Point vs EO Tech thread. I still want to work some more with my irons, because I am humbled to the point of knowing how much room I have to improve. I have still not put 1000 rounds through my AR, and I want to feel totally confident in all situations with my irons before I start to cheat.

The humbling process made one other thing plenty clear, the level of weapons training that we get as Naval Aviators is poor. I learned more about tactical shooting in 3 hours at MSI than I had in the Navy up to that point. Same thing for our AW's. We train for CSAR and "train" our aircrewmen to go out on GRE elements, but they don't really know how to use the weapons that we issue them. If I was holding the purse strings at any of the weapons school, I would be booking tickets for a team of AW's to go out to MSI and get up to speed on weapons handling. If any of your squadrons have TAD money to burn, this is the place to do it. The facilities are incredible, and the instructors have a wealth of knowledge.

Bevo gives it 2 thumbs up.
 

mmx1

Woof!
pilot
Contributor
Awesome. I keep trying to make time for a course but flight school's not amenable to taking a 3-day weekend. It looks like these folks are only doing unit/group classes; which is too bad, as they're close enough for me to drive over.

I'm a ways off from getting an optic (have to burn through a case of ammo first), but from what I've researched, the way to go (with a 1x red dot) is to get the iron sights co-witnessed through the bottom 1/3rd of the scope. That way, if the RDS fails, you're already setup to use your irons. It obviously won't work with a magnified scope as you can't see the front sight.
 

Bevo16

Registered User
pilot
It looks like these folks are only doing unit/group classes; which is too bad, as they're close enough for me to drive over.

Not only are they only doing group classes, but they are doing military/law enforcement only. I asked, it's not like you can just get 8 friends from the squadron and some cash together. No-kidding real world training for combat units only.


.... what I've researched, the way to go (with a 1x red dot) is to get the iron sights co-witnessed through the bottom 1/3rd of the scope. That way, if it fails, if the RDS fails, you're already setup to use your irons. It obviously won't work with a magnified scope as you can't see the front sight.

I am stuck between the Aimpoint Comp M3 and the EO Tech XPS. Both of those can do exactly what you are talking about with the co-witness. I like the "doughnut of death" of the EO Tech, and also the fact that the center dot is only 1 MOA. I like the look of the aimpoint better, and the 2 MOA dot is simple and does not clutter your field of view. Maybe I will flip a coin.

I keep coming back to the idea of the ACOG, mostly because if I am going to spend $500 or more, it would be nice to get some magnification out of it. It kind of defeats the purpose of "speed" though. I just have to decide what I want my AR set up for, and I am leaning toward the close range set up.

My practical side tells me that if I am ever going to have to shoot something beyond 150 yards, I will either have enough time to go and get my M1A or re-think my actions and avoid going to jail. Going with the red-dot will also save me a few hundred bucks that I can put toward a Leupold and mount for my M1A.

OR, I can go over to the LaRue site and go nuts. After all, their QD mounts return to zero and I can get one of each and just swap them out whenever I want. Maybe I will get the wife an optic for mother's day. Think she will go for that?
 

H60Gunner

Registered User
Contributor
That's some awesome stuff Bevo.

Wrt AW's, CSAR and guns. I was around when the mission was dropped in our laps, and became the squadron gun guy.

Actually, I am the first AW (that I know of) to obtain an 0812 NEC before AW was a source rate. It involved some deception but I think it was planned that way to pave the way for us to attend the school.

Anyway, in the olden days when we were scrambling to become CSAR proficient, we of course relied heavily on the SEALs for advice, training, and "how the fuck are we gonna do this" shit. They were great but are extremely busy and were not available as much as we would have liked and needed. Sending everyone to MSI sounds like another excellent option.
 

lmnop

Active Member
I keep coming back to the idea of the ACOG, mostly because if I am going to spend $500 or more, it would be nice to get some magnification out of it. It kind of defeats the purpose of "speed" though. I just have to decide what I want my AR set up for, and I am leaning toward the close range set up.

I know I'm a broken record on this one, but an ACOG set up with a Docter or J-Point up top really does give you the best of both worlds. I switched from an EoTech/BUIS setup to ACOG/J-Point and have absolutely no complaints.
 

Bevo16

Registered User
pilot
I know I'm a broken record on this one, but an ACOG set up with a Docter or J-Point up top really does give you the best of both worlds. I switched from an EoTech/BUIS setup to ACOG/J-Point and have absolutely no complaints.

Oh, I have no doubt that is a good setup. It is just that it costs more that the weapon itself.

I have one kid and 9 hungry guns to feed.
 

lmnop

Active Member
Oh, I have no doubt that is a good setup. It is just that it costs more that the weapon itself.

I have one kid and 9 hungry guns to feed.

True enough, it is alot of coin. One compromise I've shot is the Leupold CQT which runs about the same as a bare ACOG pricewise and gives you the 1x dot option and 1-3 variable....I didn't dig it though since it just seemed to be mediocre in a few roles rather than great at one. A few guys I know really like them though, so they may be worth at least looking at.
 

wlawr005

Well-Known Member
pilot
Contributor
Most AW's that I know have spent more time posing for pics with their M-4 than actually shooting it..:icon_smil
 
Top