Brandon,
I'm an MO at Boston U. The MO board is looking for the well rounded individual - athletic, intelligent, future leader. I'm not sure how my application compared to others that got the scholarship but I'll give you my stats. I played soccer, hockey (captain), and track (all state), was VP of my senior class, did a lot of community service, had a 3.4 gpa and a 1260 sat. My PFT was a 260 when I applied (12 pullups, 100 situps, 17:54 run) although its a 300 now w/a 16:20 run. I honestly think my two interviews are what got me the scholarship though. You need to go in there confident, looking sharp, and tell them how much of a stud you are, how much you love your country, and how the character you have gained through all your experiences in addition to the training you will receive from the Marine Corps will allow you to effectively lead America's most elite troops. But I'm assuming you've already done all this since its already April. How'd it go?
Pat