I'm more of a handgun guy, and admittedly, my Garand response was more of a "word association" thing. As in, when Wink says "you can only have one rifle," what's the first thing that pops into your head? Thought about it more and this came to mind . . .
I'm still anal about the whole semi-auto thing, though. It's so intuitive. Point. Click. I suppose a Scout-like semi-auto would be a pretty good deal.
Nittany, I think I understand the whole "scout rifle" concept, but why does every one have the optic mounted so far forward? Wouldn't there be eye relief problems with a scope mounted so far forward?