aggiepilot,
You answer your own question. There is no telling the type of pilot one is or the quality of his training or experience based on a FAA issued license and a log book. Some flying certainly shows apptitude. Fact is that by time a guy gets to advance training it is a crap shoot who will have the best grades. Nothing a typical private pilot learns or experiences prepares him for the gun pattern, CV landings, slung loads in a helo or multiple engine failures in a P-3. If a guy can afford some flight time he should get it. If he can't shouldn't worry about it.
You answer your own question. There is no telling the type of pilot one is or the quality of his training or experience based on a FAA issued license and a log book. Some flying certainly shows apptitude. Fact is that by time a guy gets to advance training it is a crap shoot who will have the best grades. Nothing a typical private pilot learns or experiences prepares him for the gun pattern, CV landings, slung loads in a helo or multiple engine failures in a P-3. If a guy can afford some flight time he should get it. If he can't shouldn't worry about it.