I originally applied for Pilot and NFO, and was incredibly fortunate to be selected for both.
eyesight had slipped to 20/50
So I accepted Naval Flight Officer, and started preparing for that course.
I know this is a great opportunity, and I'm incredibly fortunate to be in this position.
These points from your post sound very familiar to me. I was selected for both Pilot and NFO (in that order also) in October. Pilot has been a dream of mine since before my older brother (5 yrs older) can remember. I also agree that we were both extremely fortunate for the opportunity.
Then the wonderful experience that is MEPS said my eyes were 20/70. However, I know my eyes are not that bad. I know this because I had an eye exam about 6 months before MEPS and one a month after that have both resulted in 20/30 left and 20/25 right.
Could I have stopped the process and reapplied with a return to MEPS and passing eyes? Yes I could have. But I wanted to take my shot now and there were to many unknown variables to reapplying. Even then it all depended if my eyes would pass MEPS on a return trip.
A few things that made me go ahead and swear in, I wanted to be an officer in the Navy. If I only would have accepted Pilot, I wouldn't have put my other 2 options on my application. I was still a little dissappointed that I was DQ'd from pilot when I know that the MEPS test wasn't accurate, but there will be plenty of other experiences that the Navy will provide me with other than just flying. I know that my civilian career will never be able to give me those kinds of experiences. I will also have a awesome job as an NFO and I couldn't be more excited that I have this opportunity to be a part of the best Navy in the world.
Like others have posted, it is Officer first and Pilot/NFO second. If you decide to go ahead with NFO, you will still be in the air and have a small chance to redes later. Each selection board is a mistery and no one knows why they got selected, so there is no way to know that you will get picked up again.
I was in a similiar situation and I didn't hesitate to swear in and take my opportunity. Things happen for a reason and I'm sure I will not regret my decision anytime in the future. You said your class is coming soon, so what is your class date? I will be in the 9 May OCS class. Let us know what you decide.