This thing has been out for awhile. For those of you who have seen it, how accurately does it depict carrier life?
http://www.pbs.org/weta/carrier/
http://www.pbs.org/weta/carrier/
-
Please take a moment and update your account profile. If you have an updated account profile with basic information on why you are on Air Warriors it will help other people respond to your posts. How do you update your profile you ask?
Go here:
Edit Account Details and Profile
"Carrier" PBS Documentary
- Thread starter TAMR
- Start date
Great Navy Documentary ----> "Down Periscope"
R
russellf54
Guest
+1. Great film about Navy life. McHales Navy is a close second.
About the same as this is for the Army:
Hillarious. How had I not seen this before?
That is pretty freakin' funny haha. Is Carrier really THAT far off? Is there a big separation of power between Enlisted and Officers? Even Junior Officers?
fattestfoot
In it for the naked volleyball
Wait, I don't get it? That Onion parody is dead on about the Army, and from your tone it sounds like you think Carrier doesn't represent ship life at all.
Well I can't speak from experience for the Army but i'll assume its accurate. Are you saying then that "Carriers" is fairly accurate? Is the separation of power between Officers and Enlisted as evident as it is in the show? Being an officer/Naval Aviator looks pretty "cush" when they aren't flying. All officers have "side jobs" right?
Exactly.
What they're not showing are the hours of mission planning, briefing, flying, and debriefing...followed by burning the midnight oil by writing FitReps and awards, un-screwing DTS claims, maintaining NATOPS programs, developing load plans for future movements, standing ODO/SDO/IWO/Paddles/Tower Flower/etc duties, setting up piss tests, etc. While the work isn't nearly as "hands-on" as our Marines/Sailors, it is just as busy...albeit behind the scenes most of the time.
fattestfoot
In it for the naked volleyball
I should have quoted 1rotorhead there, as my comment was directed at him, not you. I've never been in the Navy, and all my working experience was with enlisted (and even then it was mostly SEALs or Seabees, and I don't think they really represent the rest of Big Navy).
Edit: and maybe should've quoted Ray-Ban for this, since KBay ninja posted before me.
Oh, and also to add, I've read complaints from those in Naval Aviation about the series in that it almost entirely focuses on FA-18 squadrons, and completely ignores everyone else. I enjoy watching it every now and then, but that part does irritate me a bit.
Edit: and maybe should've quoted Ray-Ban for this, since KBay ninja posted before me.
Oh, and also to add, I've read complaints from those in Naval Aviation about the series in that it almost entirely focuses on FA-18 squadrons, and completely ignores everyone else. I enjoy watching it every now and then, but that part does irritate me a bit.
As a current Enlisted sailor with an OCS package in I will try to answer this. There is definitely a pretty big power difference between enlisted and officer. On the JO to Chief level not so much, although Chiefs will still always refer to JO's as Sir and show them the respect required. Chiefs are responsible for helping to mentor Junior Officers even though JOs outrank them so chiefs will be quick to put a JO in line (usually behind closed doors). It is a complicated situation, but it works and has worked for a long time. As far as the power difference in the documentary Carrier, that is pretty dead on. I was actually impressed with the level of authenticity in the show. -On a side note my Master Chief (who just retired last week) was Master Chief Penton - the CMC from that show. He is EXACTLY the same in person as he is in that show.
"Carrier" came out while i was on deployment. I've never seen it but heard it was pretty realistic. I posted the link because i thought it was funny and dead on.
