Reserves seems like a good home for TACRON. Long term steady manning for an important, but fringe to the rest of the navy, mission.
Wouldn't work. You'd have to MOB a det for every LHA float, plus workups. You'd basically be asking people to volunteer to be in a non-flying hardware squadron, and even the SELRES hardware squadrons don't do full-length deployments. Or find some way to rotate TACC dets on and off the boat in 2- or 3-month intervals, which would cause its own issues. Imagine CAG Ops, Air Ops, or Strike Ops were staffed with reservists who got rotated out on 8-week intervals during cruise. Bet you INDOPACOM and PACFLT aren't going to plan their ESG port calls around that nonsense.
SELRES TACRON is hypothetically manned, trained, and equipped to provide 4 additional TACC dets (1 per TACRON SAU) to the fleet on a full mobilization. After 5 years, I still have no idea what NR TACGRU 1 is really for, other than providing additional CAOC bodies for AT every year and giving one post-command SELRES O-6 the ability to be called "Commodore." We tried getting folks afloat when I was 12's reserve OPSO, it was a huge pain train, and we ultimately got told "stuff it, there's no overflow berthing on board ship." Everyone just wants to hit the easy button and send the reservists off to the CAOC, and the heck with them being TACCWO qualled.
Plus it's not long-term steady manning when folks have PRDs just like the AC.