Tell that to the guy I went through Primary with that aced his I4390. Yes, that's right. ACED it. And went helos anyway.
I see what you're saying. From what onwings have told me, it's not nearly that "easy" to get that many 5's in the Whiting sims. Take that for what it's worth. I will say that if you're able to hold +/- 20' in general, let alone 0' in the sim, you're doing alright. When they send us for our annual sim hop, I usually spend the first 10 minutes recovering from unusual attitudes. I hate those things.
If we're talking about the same guy, he also went on to be diagnosed with diabetes and got medically retired.
Yeah, some of those things just don't want to fly straight. I think whoever wrote the software accidentally added a minus sign to some stability equation and gave the damn things anhedral.
Someone was telling me about that guy recently. Talk about some bad news.
One of the sim guys told me that the system is designed to take constant input so as to simulate the inherit randomness of moving through an airmass. As such, if it detects no input from the pilot (because you've trimmed it well and are on profile), it will put in it's own input to knock it off the current trim. Of course the result is that it becomes completely unstable and makes you work harder than you would in the plane (not to mention making the first flight back in the plane a relearning experience for the first 10-15 minutes).
The "answer" was to just jiggle the stick an inch or so back in forth while flying straight and level and the system will read that as input and not put in its two cents. I can't remember if that was for the old sims or the new ones, but I found it worked at times, but it wasn't full-proof.